Every political and national movement in the world depends for its survival and success not only on passion but also on awareness, discipline and strategy. History shows that many movements have suffered less from the strength of the external enemy and more from their own internal weaknesses, carelessness and personality cults. The struggle for Balochistan’s freedom and national survival is also passing through such a delicate phase, where, along with sacrifice, loyalty and passion, the need for secrecy, organisational awareness and collective responsibility has grown more than ever.
In today’s digital age, when every word, picture and identity can become part of a surveillance system within moments, the question has become extremely important: is the aim of the national struggle to highlight oneself and one’s identity, or to secure the collective interest and continuity of the movement? Should our focus be on promoting the individual, or on the ideology and organisation that are far more lasting and important than individuals? This is the fundamental question that invites us to understand the difference between “I” and “we” and to reflect on the real demands of the struggle.
Now, if we look at this secrecy through a Baloch lens, we have to think about Pakistan’s lavish budget and assets. Along with its intelligence agencies, it has set all its military and intelligence machinery and technology on the trail of Baloch youth twenty-four hours a day, and it has begun this work very seriously.
And what are Baloch youth doing? Baloch sons have now become so “clever” that on Instagram and TikTok they put their name, write their area, post their picture, and then what do they write? That I support the armed struggle. They post their picture with Ustad Mir Ahmed’s revolutionary songs and write such captions about freedom that not just ordinary Pakistanis but even the agencies are set on fire: “I am for my nation”, “I want freedom”, “I am a friend of this martyr”, “I am inspired by this martyr’s ideology”. How much time do you think this young man will have? Two days at most? Two weeks? Two months? Six months? About three weeks ago, one such young comrade disappeared whom we always used to warn about exactly this.
Because the CTD, ISI, local death squads and MI men are also sitting there; they have informers in every area and the names of thousands of young people. They search them one by one, and as soon as they see such a post, a file on that young man is immediately prepared. And it is bound to be so, because unfortunately the enemy has neither a psyche like ours, nor our foolish bravado, nor the time to waste on pointless social media debates and posting radical things under its own identity.
Now what is that amateur son, being humiliated in a torture cell, to do? He is not even connected to any armed or political struggle, let alone useful to it. But for the enemy, his posts are proof that he has been supporting these things. Now don’t you think, God forbid, his life could become useless to the movement as well? Forget the movement—useless to himself too. Now every day some filthy state officials barge into his house with their stinking presence, smash things, torture his white-bearded parents, dishonour his sisters and steal valuables from his home—who is responsible? What if he is kept in torture cells for years? What if he is kept in closed rooms for years? What if he is asked for the names of his comrades? And what if, because of him, other innocent people also end up in those same torture chambers? Who will be responsible, in the end?
Years ago Kamash said something very important that, in my view, every Baloch thirsting for freedom should engrave in their mind: “From everything I have observed and studied, I have understood that every loss, big or small, the Baloch movement has suffered to this day has been rooted only in our own negligence, loose thinking, laziness and carelessness.
And revealing secrets does not only mean sitting and talking or sharing information; one aspect of breaking secrecy is also giving impressions through your gatherings, your manner, your area, your company and even your thoughts and ideas that lift the veil. Because it is almost impossible for any loss to happen without negligence and weakness inside the movement.”
Today, in the freedom struggle in Balochistan, every person has two worlds, and these two must be kept separate at any cost. The first world: you and the people who know you personally, who are physically with you—your close friends, your neighbours, even your family members. Say nothing here, stay limited here, because those who know you can harm you—deliberately or by mistake, intentionally or accidentally, consciously or unconsciously, directly or indirectly, openly or secretly, rightly or wrongly, from near or far. Your parents’ worry, a sister’s foolishness, a friend’s mistake, a few words slipping from their mouths, and you are in those torture cells, from which a safe return can only be a matter of chance.
The second world: you and the people connected only on the basis of ideology, whom you do not know and who do not know you, whom you meet only on the internet or in diwan circles. Here you can talk, but only for the struggle, nothing more. These two worlds must never meet. Who you are at home is not who you are on the internet.
So it is not unlikely that many people will not be willing to accept this, and many will find it a very simple point. But for a realist, this is the very thinking that keeps the spirit of the armed struggle alive.
Secrecy means becoming a different person in the two worlds. At home you are one person; on the internet you are another. Your names may be different, your areas may be different, but there must be no link between the two showing that they are the same person.
Now, if someone wants to use social media effectively, they should learn first. Learn what propaganda is and how it works, how a narrative is built, what people believe and what they don’t, and how a powerful message can be given even under an anonymous name.
Finally, it is very important to understand what the real focus should be. Should we stay caught up in displaying the individual, or put the continuity of the organisation and the movement first? The question is: should the centre of attention be “I” or “we”?
The real point is that when ideology prevails, personality stays behind, and when personality prevails, ideology fades. If a person constantly keeps themselves at the centre, their identity may shine for a while, but their ideas become limited. And if they lose themselves in the ideology, their ideas move ahead of their time.
It is a fact that the world has moved far ahead. Technology, information and intelligence have all become so advanced that no secret can stay secret for long. But in this same world, another reality is sleeper cell operations, and on the other side are our Baloch sons and daughters who are in torture cells because of their emotions, without having done anything.
***